« The Lonely Grill | Main | Comfort Food »

Bourbonless Pumpkin Cheesecake

Cheesecakes are sly creatures. They make me very nervous. Why do they jiggle so when they are thoroughly cooked? I always panic and leave the cheesecake in the oven until it no longer jiggles, terrified that I'll have a soggy, runny mess if I don't. And I never have a runny mess, because I always overcook cheesecake. So, when I made a pumpkin cheesecake this weekend for a dinner party thrown by Gentleman Caller's colleague, I decided to go against my better judgment and cook the cheesecake for exactly the time prescribed by the recipe. If it didn't work, well, at least it would be spectacularly embarrassing to show up with a partially cooked dessert. But it did work! For once, I finally turned out a cheesecake that wasn't dry, thick and cracked, but moist and cheesecakey.

The cheesecake was officially a Bourbon Pumpkin Cheesecake, but I omitted the bourbon as the hosts have children and I didn't know how they felt about feeding alcohol to their kids. Turns out, they don't mind a bit. I think the bourbon would have rounded out the flavor nicely. There was a sour cream topping to the cheesecake, which was OK, but I think I'll try a new topping next time, or just forget it. The crust, though, was excellent. Walnut and graham crackers, brown sugar and butter. Yum.

Comments

I take a pumpkin cheesecake to the cabin every year for Thanksgiving, with threats of lynching if I don't. We can have a pumpkin cheesecakeoff...

I, personally, would like to get this recipe and try it. And soon. Please.

good job! a victory for cheesecakes everywhere. I highly recommend, for those seeking epic cheesecake, the recipe on Epicurious for Almond Blackberry cheesecake. Stop drooling on your computer.

Red Meat,
Would that be the same as the "Almond Cheesecake With Sour Cream And Blackberries" from Bon Appétit? If so, it looks really good...

yes indeedy it is. I made it for my friend's Seder dinner last year. It was funny because all through dinner, which is this big religious production involving themes of suffering and redemption, all I could think about was the upcoming cheesecake. I am a terrible Jew. But I make great cheesecake.